Some Massachusetts lawmakers are seeking to prohibit landlords from using software that recommends apartment rents based on nonpublic leasing information from other properties. The proposal targets a practice known in the real estate industry as revenue management, in which computer programs analyze market data and suggest price changes intended to increase rental income.
The issue has gained attention because renters may not know that an algorithm helped set the price of a unit. The software can examine information supplied by participating landlords, including advertised rents, the amounts tenants actually pay after discounts and lease terms for both new agreements and renewals. It also tracks expected demand and occupancy, according to MassLive.
How the pricing systems work
These programs process leasing information from properties using the service and monitor changes in local markets. They then recommend when a landlord should raise or lower a listed rent. The systems are used across the country, with data drawn from millions of properties, according to the report.
RealPage, a Texas-based company, is described as the largest provider in the industry. The company says on its website that landlords using its service outperform competitors that do not use it by as much as 7%. The figure is the company’s claim, not an independent finding presented in the report.
| Information used by the software | What it can help recommend |
|---|---|
| Listed rent and discounted lease price | Changes to asking rents |
| Lease length for new tenants and renewals | Pricing for different lease terms |
| Expected demand and occupancy | Whether prices should move with anticipated demand |
Critics have accused landlords that use these systems of unfair pricing, deliberately keeping apartments empty and coordinating with other landlords in ways that reduce competition. Those accusations are not the same as a legal finding. The report does not identify a final ruling establishing that every landlord or software provider using such systems violated the law.
“This is a much more sophisticated way of looking at all the rents than actually trying to understand what the maximum the market will bear in a given community is,” state Rep. Lindsay Sabadosa, D-1st Hampshire, said.
Sabadosa compared the approach with a landlord or seller reviewing prices for similar homes before setting an asking price. She said the algorithmic systems can create continuing upward pressure on rents and make it harder for people to remain in their communities.
What lawmakers are considering
Some Massachusetts legislators now want to outlaw algorithmic rent pricing altogether. The report does not describe the measure as enacted law. It presents the effort as a proposal under consideration by lawmakers, so landlords and tenants remain subject to existing rules unless and until a new measure passes and takes effect.
The debate reflects a broader question for rental markets: whether a landlord’s pricing decision is based on public information about comparable apartments or on shared, nonpublic data supplied by competing property owners. For tenants, that distinction can affect how a listed monthly rent is established even when the property’s location, size, condition and amenities have not changed.
- Revenue-management software can use rents, discounts, lease terms, demand and occupancy information to recommend prices.
- RealPage says its customers can outperform landlords that do not use the service by up to 7%.
- Massachusetts lawmakers are seeking a ban, but the report describes the measure as a proposal rather than an enacted rule.