A Colorado federal court has granted judgment on the pleadings to three credit reporting agencies in a lawsuit brought under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, or FCRA. The ruling involved a consumer who alleged that a lease termination agreement eliminated an outstanding rental balance.
Judgment on the pleadings is a decision based on the allegations and other pleadings filed in a case, without a trial on the full merits. According to Hinshaw & Culbertson, the court concluded that the dispute, as presented, concerned what the lease agreement legally did to the debt. The court treated that issue differently from a straightforward factual error, such as reporting the wrong balance.
Why the distinction matters
The FCRA requires credit reporting agencies to investigate certain consumer disputes and requires companies that provide information to credit bureaus, known as furnishers, to respond when a bureau forwards a dispute. The Colorado decision illustrates an argument increasingly used in FCRA litigation: A credit bureau may contend that it is not required to resolve a dispute that depends on interpreting a contract or deciding a legal question.
That defense did not provide the same protection to the debt collector that reported the rental balance, according to the law firm’s account. The collector allegedly continued confirming the balance after receiving disputes without contacting the consumer or checking with the landlord. The collector settled rather than litigating, so the allegations against it were not resolved through a court finding.
“This decision provides yet another distinction on the trend of ‘legal versus factual inaccuracy’ defense under the FCRA.” — Justin Penn, Hinshaw partner
The court also indicated that some disagreements involving contracts can present factual questions that are suitable for an FCRA claim. It gave the plaintiff permission to amend the complaint. That means the ruling did not necessarily end every possible version of the consumer’s case, even though the court granted the agencies’ request based on the pleadings before it.
Implications for companies reporting debts
Justin Penn wrote in the AccountsRecovery.net ARM Compliance Digest that furnishers should not rely exclusively on the legal-versus-factual distinction. He said companies should document how they process disputes and, when possible, verify the debt with the creditor. The comments are compliance guidance from Penn, not a new federal rule.
The decision also reflects the significance of the “objectively and readily verifiable” standard identified by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, according to Hinshaw’s summary. That standard governs claims against furnishers under FCRA Section 1681s-2(b), the provision addressing a furnisher’s duties after a credit bureau sends it a dispute.
- The Colorado court granted three credit reporting agencies judgment on the pleadings.
- The dispute centered on the legal effect of a lease termination agreement, not simply an incorrect reported balance.
- The debt collector allegedly continued verifying the balance and later settled, while the consumer was allowed to amend the complaint.
The ruling does not establish that credit bureaus can disregard every dispute involving a contract. Its significance lies in the court’s treatment of the particular allegations and in the continuing distinction between information that is factually wrong and information whose legal consequences remain contested.